| In
1918 the United States ratified a treaty with Great Britain on behalf of
Canada to protect and manage 212 species of birds that migrated annually
between the two countries. The list included all waterfowl, all migratory game
birds (doves, woodcock, snipe, etc.), and nearly all songbirds. Many migratory
birds were purposely excluded such as cormorants, hawks, owls, and pelicans.
The reason was generally the damage they cause and the need to control them
when and where they cause problems independent of treaty restrictions. This
approach worked fine for 50 years. Jurisdiction over birds named on the treaty
was thereby transferred from State governments to the Federal government as
provided in Article VI of the Constitution.
The Secretary of the Interior was given the
responsibility for implementing and enforcing the treaty's provisions. Primary
Management Authority over all migratory game birds, control of all
depredations by protected migratory birds, and research related to life
histories and management needs was vested first in the Bureau of Biological
Survey and then in it's successor the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS.) From
the 1920's until the 1970's migratory birds were the primary purpose of FWS
refuges, land acquisition, law enforcement, research, and the second priority
(after western stock protection from predators on public lands) for FWS damage
control employees.
In the late 1960's FWS employees worked with
UN and IUCN employees to adopt the IUCN Red Book as the predecessor to the
Endangered Species Act that they drafted and lobbied through Congress in the
early 1970's along with the Marine Mammal Protection Act. The early
interactions between these Federal bureaucrats and their UN counterparts
focused on the "lack" of Federal protection (even though they were
doing just fine under State government authorities) for cormorants, hawks,
owls, and pelicans. They contrived to show a "need" for new bird
treaties with Japan and the Soviet Union since we also "shared"
birds with them in the North Pacific. The treaties sailed through (it was the
sunrise of environmental awareness and concern) with the hawks and owls and
cormorants and pelicans listed even though only a few of those species were
"shared" with the Japanese or the Russians. The other two treaties
(Mexico and Canada) were subsequently adjusted to cover all the same species.
In the 1970's FWS began to sense a new role
with great power and funding potential. As public evidence of it's new role
"saving" "Endangered Species" and "Marine
Mammals" FWS began shedding it's reputation as a manager of birds
"for the gun." An early move in this direction was "restoring
the Giant Canada Goose in the upper Midwest. This was not for "the
gun" but for the environment and urban and semi-urban nature lovers that
were known to be supportive of the new FWS role. Permits for towns like
Rochester, Minnesota were issued to breed and release Canada Geese (a
protected migratory bird.) Other cities and golf courses and parks soon wanted
the "beautiful birds" for their area. Permits were issued and what
were mostly medium to large (Canada geese, like humans, have a wide variety of
sizes) Canada geese began popping up all over the Midwest and the East. FWS no
more knew what they were getting into than they do about wolf introductions or
waterfowl contamination of heavily used marshes. Studies about wild Canada
geese like studies of wild wolves are no more a gauge to their behavior or
food habits in urban areas than observations of killer whales in the Aleutians
are to a killer whale from Seattle living in a tank in Florida. So the rest
is, as they say, history. Overpopulating and non-migratory (resident) Canada
geese for the first decade were trucked from Dulles airport or Connecticut
golf courses to Georgia and West Virginia. Sometimes they beat the FWS
employees back to their home and sometimes they stayed on a reservoir or an
industrial park pond or on a local creek or even in swimming pools. By the
1980's FWS had to abandon moving all of the overpopulating Canada geese
(wolf-lovers and rural residents and suburban dog owners take note) because of
costs and the sheer magnitude of the problem. Permits were no longer even
considered. Concurrent with this debacle, uncontrolled cormorant populations
ballooned in the Mississippi watershed and on the Great Lakes. Catfish
farmers, hatchery operators, sport fishermen, and commercial fishermen all
began to howl. Like the similarly unmanaged North Atlantic seals the
cormorants obvious impact on sport fish, commercial fish, hatcheries, and
human health around colonies was denied and urban residents came to believe
that any reduction in their record numbers was tantamount to endangering the
birds with "extinction." |