|
The
Washington Times reports that Earle D. Hightower, chairman of the 27-member
Institute for Public Safety - a group concerned with issues such as traffic
and air pollution in Rockville, Md. - recently sent out 600 cards to property
owners in Garrett County stating that 40 percent of hunters are drug addicts,
drunks or mentally unstable.
Mr. Hightower, 82, who says he is a former
hunter and World War II veteran, was quoted as saying, "My personal
opinion is that anybody who goes out and shoots helpless animals has a
psychiatric problem."
These are the days of fact-checking. As a
psychologist, I'd like to report back on my fact-checking.
Because I am an adjunct faculty member at a
professional graduate school of psychology, I was able to conduct a search of
the ProQuest Psychology search engine that indexes more than 400 journals in
the fields of anthropology, psychology and psychiatry.
It found 258 articles that use the word
"hunting." I checked them all. None report on any studies of hunting
and mental illness.
I've spoken with the Research Department of
the American Psychological Association. They agree that they are not aware of
any studies to support Mr. Hightower's claim that hunters are prone to mental
illness. In fact, the opposite seems true.
Many of the best-respected behavioral
scientists of our times, including Sigmund Freud, William James, Carl Jung,
Erich Fromm, Marie-Louise von Franz and Karl Menninger, have written that
hunting is a natural, healthy part of human nature.
Hunting is a very basic instinct programmed
into the master computer of our species for survival purposes that has been
elevated by ethics to become a "sport," which enables us to express
our basic biological identity, "The Id," guided social ethics,
religious teachings and laws.
Erich Fromm, one of the most widely-respected
behavioral scientists of the 20th century, summed up these opinions in his
widely-acclaimed study of the causes and prevention of violence, "The
Anatomy of Human Destructiveness":
In the act of hunting, a man becomes, however
briefly, part of nature again. He returns to the natural state, becomes one
with the animal, and is freed from the burden of his existential split: to be
part of nature and to transcend it by virtue of his consciousness. In stalking
the animal he and the animal become equals, even though man eventually shows
his superiority by use of his weapons.
Fromm goes on to point out that the
motivation of the modern ethical sport hunter is pleasure fused with
compassion. He also states that this contrasts sharply with the motivation of
the sadist, who might torture and kill pets or other small animals, which is
revenge.
In short, hunting and pet torture, are as
unalike as sexual intercourse in a loving relationship and rape.
"Predatory aggression," as Fromm
calls hunting, is a positive form of aggression, like sport and play, the
expression of which is good for mind, body and spirit.
Melvin Konner in his award-winning book
"The Tangled Wing," based on a seven-year study of the biological
origins of human behavior supported by the National Institute of Mental
Health, the Emory University professor of psychiatry and anthropology states,
"… There is little or no evidence, physiological or behavioral, to
suggest that predatory aggression has much in common with intraspecies
aggression."
This may help explain why hunters are among
the most ardent conservationists. Non-hunting environmentalist groups often
survive on crises, real or fabricated, which fuel fund-raising. Hunting groups
put their money into habitat, resulting often in more results, not more hot
air.
|