| In
1992 a review paper, A Survey Of Potential Impacts Of Boating Activity On
Estuarine Productivity, was presented the Marine Engines And Vessels Public
Workshop sponsored by U.S.E.P.A. Office of Air and Radiation in Ann Arbor,
Michigan (the article is available at www.fishingnj.org/artobm1.htm).
In large part because of this review, in 1994
a Boating Impacts Workshop was held at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute
in Woods Hole, MA. In three days 50 researchers, environmentalists and agency
folks reviewed the current "state of the science" regarding the
possible environmental impacts of intensive boating activities. Not
surprisingly, the consensus of the attendees was that such impacts had been
largely ignored, might be significant in some instances, and that much more
research was needed.
Workshop proceedings, including an extensive
bibliography, were transcribed, distributed and posted on the WHOI website (the
proceedings are no longer available there but have been posted in part on the
NJ Fishing website at www.fishingnj.org/pdfs/boatingimpacts.pdf).
In the ten years since this workshop much
better emission controls have been developed for both two stroke and four
stroke outboard motors, reducing the levels of unburned fuel and combustion
products released to the water column. However, the significant increase in the
size of outboard motors and the boats they are pushing since then (a 25 foot
boat with twin 150 to 200 horsepower engines used to be the "dream
machine" for the go-fast recreational fishing/boating crowd, but today
it's a 30 footer with three 200 to 300 horsepower engines) might be in part
compensating for the cleaner engines. This, coupled with the extended service
life of old - and still heavily polluting - engines, makes it difficult to
judge where we stand vis a vis regarding emissions of unburned fuel and
combustion products into our waterways..
And fisheries researchers who should be
concerned have yet to address the impacts to estuarine organisms caused by
propeller (inboard, inboard/outboard and outboard boats) or impeller (personal
watercraft) generated turbulence or vessel hull passage.
We're well aware of the impacts that the
propellers on rapidly traveling vessels can have on larger animals like turtles
and manatees. It's hard to imagine that they don't have similar impacts on
smaller organisms, either through direct contact with the blades or through the
turbulence they create (if you doubt this, imagine the forces a small fish or
invertebrate would be exposed to in passing through the maelstrom caused by the
propeller of an outboard or inboard/outboard powered boat traveling at high
speed).
Impacts of electrical generation
For years we've been aware of the possible
damage inflicted on our estuaries by the cooling systems of electrical
generating stations. A base load power plant using once-through cooling
requires on the order of a million gallons a minute of ambient water to cool
its condensers. Elaborate modifications to the cooling systems are required to
reduce the damage to organisms entrained in the cooling water or impinging on
the intake screens. Building and maintaining these systems and the other
operational modifications designed to reduce the environmental impacts of
once-through cooling systems cost billions of dollars a year, but these costs
are willingly born by the various utilities' share holders and rate payers to
preserve the ecological integrity of our estuaries.
|