In "The Development of
Advanced Hydroelectric Turbines to Improve Fish Passage Survival,"
published in Fisheries, the journal of the American Fisheries Society (vol 26
no 9), Glenn Cada lists the threats to fish from passage through turbines.
These threats, which are similar in fossil fuel and nuclear powered and
hydroelectric generating stations, are:
- rapid and extreme pressure changes (water
pressures within the turbine may increase to several times atmospheric
pressure,
then drop to subatmospheric pressure, all in a matter of seconds),
- cavitation (extremely low water pressures
cause the formation of vapor bubbles which subsequently collapse violently),
- shear stress (forces applied parallel to the
fish's surface resulting from the incidence of two bodies of water of
different velocities),
- turbulence (irregular motions of the water,
which can cause localized injuries or, at larger scales, disorientation),
- strike (collision with structures including
runner blades, stay vanes, wicket gates, and draft tube piers),
- and grinding (squeezing through narrow
gaps between fixed and moving structures).
Aside from "grinding," each of these
threats can also be attributed to the propeller of an outboard or
inboard/outboard motor or the impeller of a personal watercraft at speed.
Impacts of small boats
Consider a boat traveling at thirty miles per
hour. It will have a propeller with a diameter of perhaps 15 inches rotating at
somewhere between 1500 and 2500 revolutions per minute. As small, rapidly
rotating propellers do, as it rotates it cavitates, vaporizing the water it
passes through in what can best be described as an ongoing explosion. If the
propeller is rotating at 2,000 rpm, at their periphery the blades are moving
through the water at almost 100 miles per hour.
At a vessel speed of thirty mph the propeller
will pass through approximately a million and a half gallons or 5 acre/feet of
water in an hour of operation.[1]
Thus forty boats traveling at 30 miles per hour
impact as great a volume of water, and the organisms in it, as a base load
generating station.
A "target" estuary
Barnegat Bay is a large, shallow estuary lying
behind New Jersey's barrier islands. Approximately 40 miles long, approaching 5
miles at its widest, it has an area of 47,615 acres. With an average depth of
4.6 feet, it has a total volume of 220,000 acre feet. A decade ago Barnegat Bay
had over 200 commercial marinas with a capacity to store 12,000 boats. Its
shores are heavily developed, primarily with single family residences. Many of
these have one or several boat slips as well. There were also 45 launching
ramps on the bay. According to estimates by the New Jersey Department of
Environmental Protection, over 50,000 vessels (90% power boats) used Barnegat
Bay each year. |