Index     Page 1     Page 2  |  Page 3  |  Page 4  |  Page 5  |  Page 6   |  Page 7  |  Page 8  |  Page 9  |  Download

IWMC - World Conservation Trust
MAINPAGE

SUSTAINABLE USE

ELEPHANTS
FISH
MAMMALS
REPTILES
SEALS
SEA TURTLES
SHARKS
WHALES

ABOUT IWMC

CENSORED

CONTACT IWMC

eNEWSLETTERS
April
EVENTS CALENDAR
MEDIA RELEASES

SEARCH

WEB LINKS

eNewsletter

April 2002

IWMC
World Conservation Trust

 
Editorial: Milking the Shock Value
of Cultural Insult

by Janice Henke, Anthropologist

 

PETA has done it again, and the media have lapped it up, as the vegetarian zealots knew they would. Just before Easter this year, PETA erected a billboard in Jackson, Mississippi, that shows an image of the Virgin Mary breastfeeding the baby Jesus. The caption accompanying the sign reads "If it was good enough for Jesus…" Naturally, enraged citizens demanded that it be taken down, but PETA spokespersons used the controversy to further their campaign against the dairy industry. Catholic League president William Donohue reportedly asserted that "The idea of showing the Blessed Mother breastfeeding baby Jesus to make a cheap point about vegetarian rights is outrageous." The ploy for media attention had worked again, and the outrage of their fellow citizens was a side effect that added to PETA's notoriety, which, of course, was their goal.

We note that in New York State, some farms have recently suffered mysterious contamination of their bulk milk tanks, with antibiotics. Of course, this is detected before the milk leaves the farm, as the pick-up tank truck driver tests each farm's product before loading it on. Any contaminants or a high bacteria count are reason for rejection of the milk before it can contaminate the common supply. The farmer is then faced with disposal of hundreds of gallons of milk and with the loss of income for the day's supply, as well as the cost of disinfecting the entire operation, investigating the cause, and preventing a recurrence. Law enforcement officials have not yet found the culprits who have done this, but farmers remember the PETA anti-dairy campaign, and are glad that the FBI has been brought in to investigate. Theories of who may have done this range from anti-dairy activists to disgruntled former employees, and security is now an added expense for farmers whose operations are barely profitable without this kind of trouble.

Make no mistake; PETA is not concerned about the health of infants or children, nor about the treatment of dairy cows, or about the environment. PETA wants to put an end to the ownership of animals by people, an end to the consumption of milk products and meat, and an end to the use of animals for medical research, transportation, sport, and entertainment. They do this by attempting to frighten, insult, disgust, and coerce people who keep and use animals and their products. The goal is to change the culture of animal users everywhere, and PETA's tactics range from the ludicrous to support of behavior that is criminal. This is disrespect for any culture that does not conform to their worldview. Such behavior must not be allowed to go beyond the limits of freedom of speech that many people cherish.