|
Sustainable
eNews |
March 2003 |
|

|
IWMC
World Conservation Trust |
|
"SEAL
WARS" "Twenty-five Years on the Front Lines with the Harp
Seals"
A book review by Janice S.
Henke, Anthropologist
|
This 240-page book by Paul Watson was published in
2003 by Firefly Books, Inc., in the USA. Price on the cover is $16.95. The
17 chapters are arranged more or less chronologically, from 1950 through
1999, and a recent photograph of the author appears on the front cover.
Watson is shown on the sea ice, holding a whitecoat seal pup in the usual
pose of one who wishes to be photographed "saving" a seal.
One might ask who might want to buy this
book. Surely, few will make the decision on the basis of an attractive
cover, because it is not. Perhaps those who have followed Watson's long
career of unending attempts at media hype, and his multiple arrests for
criminal behavior on the high seas, will wish to read his own version of
the escapades when he was involved with ineffective protest of the harp
seal hunt. Newfoundlanders and Magdalen Islanders who have a sound memory
of Watson's days in their area, would be advised to take the book in small
doses at a time, to keep their blood pressure under control. Since this
reviewer was not present at any of the adventures described, I can only say
that the descriptions, while colorful, do not resemble any Newfoundlanders,
government officials, or Magdalen Islanders whom I met during my own
observations of the seal hunt on the spring ice.
Watson's "Seal Wars" may have
been produced as a prelude to a film, long rumored to be in the making,
that will undoubtedly portray him as a hero environmentalist. The fictions
that have surfaced in this book can be expected to be embellished even more
in any such production, including the tasteless accounts of his sexual
exploits with a number of (unfortunately) named women.
Paul Watson's book will not appeal to
those who deplore the social, economic and environmental impact caused by
the International Fund for Animal Welfare, the only organization that
influenced the European market for seal products. Today, Watson still makes
noise about the increased quota for harp seals. He must chafe at the
reality of a vastly renewed market for pelts, oil, and meat. His own
actions meant nothing in the long run, and today, the harp seal herd has
grown from 1.8 million to over 5 million animals. They are hungry, they are
hurting each other, and fish of many species are showing the effects of
over-predation. Watson's Sea Shepherd Conservation Society is a small time,
ineffective outfit, whether its prey is sealers, whalers, fishermen, or
scientists. His book reflects his ego and his insensitivity to the needs of
people who wish to sustainably use their resources. He has justified his
actions with claims of cruelty to seals, and the threat of extinction.
Neither scenario has been found credible by anyone with even basic
knowledge of the seal hunt or of seal population dynamics. Watson named his
book "Seal Wars" - this writer's own 1985 choice for the title of
a book that also describes the protests, the seals, and the sealers. Paul
Watson's book will be judged by those who know the realities of seals and
sealers, fisheries officers and protesters. Only they can fairly decide
which version of the seal wars coincides with the truth. 
|