Cancun, Mexico, 10 September 2003: A leading international
environmentalist warned today that the world’s fisheries industry is
facing possible destruction not as a result of over-fishing but because
western campaign groups are targeting fisheries as "the next big
environmental issue".
Speaking at the International Symposium on Sustainable Fisheries Trade
in Cancun, Mexico, Eugene Lapointe, President of IWMC World Conservation
Trust, warned that fisheries is the next big target of environmental
campaign groups, and predicted that it will soon be discussed on a par with
global warming and the destruction of rain forests.
Mr. Lapointe, a past-Secretary General of CITES, the Convention on
International Trade in Endangered Species, made his remarks in an address
on globalization. He argued that one of the areas of globalization that
attracts little publicity is the ability it has given wealthy western
campaign groups to influence the way of life of communities in less
developed nations that may be small and remote. In the case of
environmental groups, this change is almost always destructive because,
like British imperialists in the nineteenth century, the campaigners are
trying to apply and enforce their particular brand of western values
without taking proper account of local human needs.
"The fundamental urge to subjugate one culture to the will of
another remains. The new cultural imperialist does not bash a bible; he
pushes an ecological manual in your face and demands your adherence. He
does not avow adherence to a church of the spiritually enlightened; he
professes membership in a Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) of the
morally superior. He comes not to save your soul; his flock will be your
birds, your elephants, your reptiles and your fish. He alone knows how to
care for and tend to them."
In his address, Mr. Lapointe noted that NGOs are relentlessly
campaigning to raise more money by highlighting new environmental crises
and marketing themselves as the planet’s guardians. Warning that this
type of campaigning dishonestly puts in jeopardy the livelihoods of many
different workers around the word, Mr. Lapointe said:
"The attempts by western NGOs to globalize culture can only be
counter-productive to fishermen. The NGOs do not care about jobs or local
traditions. To them, a fish ‘saved’ justifies their campaign."
Mr. Lapointe noted that fisheries has a particular attraction to NGOs
because, unlike rain forests and even whales, it is difficult to accurately
estimate fish stocks and quantify the alleged problem. Campaigners will
always be able to claim particular stocks are imperiled whether or not that
is true, and it will be very difficult to conclusively prove otherwise.
Mr. Lapointe said: "Where there are real problems with fish stocks,
management systems must be put in place. This is already happening. But
what we don’t need are simplistic slogans and unjustified restrictions,
developed by campaigners in their ivory towers, that unnecessarily rip
apart traditional fishing communities around the world." 
The full text of Mr. Lapointe’s address is available
at
www.iwmc.org/fish/030909-1.htm