Page 1 

|

 Page 2 

 

 Page 3 

 

 Page 4 

|

 Page 5 

|

 Page 6 

|

 Page 7 

IWMC - World Conservation Trust
MAINPAGE

SUSTAINABLE USE

2nd Symposium
Journal of
Sustainable Use


Introduction

Table of Contents

I Ceremonial
II Terrestrial
Resources
III  Aquatic Resources
 Marine
 Mammals
IV Issues of Relevance

Aspects of Regional Management:
Science, Sustainable Use and Conservation
of Marine Mammals in the North Atlantic

Dr. Grete Hovelsrud-Broda, Ph.D.

General Secretary
NAMMCO


Within the framework of sustainable use, it is assumed that a natural resource is used to keep a community viable and to be conserved so that the next generation will also be able to meet their needs: A resource must be used within the capacity for renewal.

Sustainable use of renewable resources combined with an effort to keep communities sustainable/viable, leads to questions regarding markets, cash and income. All contemporary societies are dependent upon a steady cash flow, and in for example many small communities in Greenland, marine mammal products remain an important source of cash. On the other hand, the pilot whale hunt drives in the Faroe Islands do not generate cash directly, but are an important source of meat for the households. In this sense the monetary replacement value is probably high. The income generated by marine mammal harvesting in Norway is also important to the overall economy of the whaling and sealing communities. Cash income and the nutritional value of marine mammals are likely to be important aspects of Icelandic whaling, if resumed. In all these cases, the social and cultural values of marine mammal hunting and the subsequent consumption and distribution of the foodstuffs must not be overlooked.

One obstacle to the sustainability of marine mammal use in some of the NAMMCO countries is the trade ban on sealskins in Europe (skins from harp and hooded seal-pups only) and the U.S. (all marine mammal products). The sealskin trade ban is not driven by market principles (i.e. international trade issues), and it is no longer motivated by a need to protect endangered species, or by concerns for environmental degradation. It is motivated by animal protectionist arguments stemming from a claim in the 1970s - 1980s, that, in particular, harp and hooded seals were endangered. Later, when it was understood that these species were not endangered, the focus of the anti-sealing controversy shifted to include all seal species. This is because perspectives of humane killing of animals and animal rights motivated the protests against sealing (and whaling). Seals and whales have a unique appeal and the notion that they are killed is disagreeable to many Western people. (This is a large and very interesting topic, but is beyond the scope of this paper.)

Marine Mammal Use in the NAMMCO Countries:
A Brief Sketch.

What is perhaps unique about NAMMCO is that all signatories have a long history of, and are currently utilizing (or have until recently utilized) marine mammals as a resource. The NAMMCO member countries share a common concern for the various species roaming the North Atlantic Ocean. Marine mammals are important to the economy, for nutrition and to the social organization of many communities in these countries.

Faroe Islands
Pilot-whale hunting in the Faroe Islands probably came to the islands with the Vikings from the Norwegian West Coast. As early as 1298 a legal document outlined who had the rights to the whales, both driven and stranded. Pilot-whale hunting in the Faroe Islands is opportunistic because the animals are driven towards and killed on the beach only when observed along the coast from boats or from land. Before the whales can be driven into one of the 23 approved bays distributed throughout the country to be killed, the hunt has to be authorized by government officials. The pilot whale hunt drive is not a commercial activity. The meat and the blubber are distributed, free of charge, to the inhabitants in the area where the whales are killed. The pilot whale is an important source of food; about one third of the annual total of meat produced in the Faroes comes from these whales (Anonymous, 1999). The pilot-whale drive hunts are instrumental in maintaining a way of life and important cultural values in the Faroe Islands.

  

Back to Top  |  Return to Aquatic Index  | BackNext Page


Go to - Mainpage IWMC World Conservation Trust