|
|
|
Aspects of Regional
Management:
Science, Sustainable Use and Conservation
of Marine Mammals in the
North Atlantic
Dr. Grete Hovelsrud-Broda, Ph.D.
General Secretary
NAMMCO
|

|
|
Harp Seals: An
Example III
Based on a request from the NAMMCO Council, the Scientific Committee provided
assessment advice on the harp seals in the White Sea, the Barents Sea, and the
Greenland Sea. The advice is based on the work of the Joint ICES/NAFO Working
Group on Harp and Hooded Seals. (This joint project is a good example of NAMMCO
working together with other organizations). The assessment was based on stock
identity, distribution and migration and on catch data and abundance estimates.
Catch options for the two stocks were developed using a model that calculates a
constant exploitation rate that will stabilize the total population at or
slightly below its current level (NAMMCO Annual Report, 1999). Based on the
Scientific Committee recommendations on stock status and catch options, the
Management Committee concluded that the catch level for 1998 was well below the
calculated replacement yield. The Management Committee also noted that catches
at the same level in the future might result in population increase. From a
resource management perspective, future quota levels approaching the replacement
yield were advised (NAMMCO Annual Report 1999). The Norwegian catches of the
harp seals, in particular, are well below the quota levels (the total quota for
harp seals for 1999 was 22,500 while the total catch was only 1,362 animals).
The Management Committee recommends that the catches approach the quota levels.
One obvious concern here is, from a multispecies interaction perspective, that
the high number of seals prey on fish targeted by the fisheries.
Conclusion
In conclusion, I will point out that in a regional and
intergovernmental organization, such as the North Atlantic Marine Mammal
Commission, sustainable use must be seen in the light of the common interest in
a region and in its resources, combined with the need to address the
socio-economic and cultural variations between the member countries. Thus, the
approach to sustainable use must take into account two separate but
interconnected factors:
- scientific studies – for determining sustainability of a species or stock.
This is an important factor shared by all the member countries;
- the socio-economic cultural and political contexts in which management
decisions are made (recall that NAMMCO does not make management decisions
only recommendations). This is allow for cultural, political and economic
diversity to be considered..
In other words, sustainable use must be considered in relation to the local
context, while it must also be solidly grounded in scientific principles that
are as objective as possible. This is a delicate balance that NAMMCO so far has
been able to uphold. The goal is to continue to strive for refinement and
understanding of the cultural, socio-economic and scientific basis of
sustainable use.
|
|