The sustainable and equitable use of living resources is now widely accepted
as an important means of protecting biodiversity and hence achieving important
conservation goals [e.g., the Brundtland Report (WCED, 1987), the World
Conservation Strategies (IUCN, 1986 and 1991), Agenda 21 and the Convention on
Biological Diversity (1993)].
However, there are individuals and animal protection organizations who
continue to believe that the consumptive use of wildlife, especially if such use
involves commercial trade, will result in the over-exploitation and possible
extinction of that species (e.g. Clark, 1991). Indeed, widespread public concern
about "endangered species" in the years since the 1972 UN Conference
on the Human Environment, has resulted in many organizations being formed in
industrialized nations, dedicated to "saving" various "endangered
species".
Although some species featured in these campaigns might indeed give cause for
legitimate conservation concern, many campaigns do not target threatened or
endangered species, but rather, species having emotionally appealing
characteristics. Indeed, some campaigns (e.g. to "Save the Whale" or
ban seal hunting) are not based on a particular species, but rather on a
readily-identifiable multi-species collectivity - be it whales, seals or
kangaroos. Here most of the species targeted by such campaigns are very abundant
and not at all endangered (Aron, 1988; Freeman, 1990). A common characteristic
of many of these campaigns to save charismatic wildlife species is the easy
recognition of the target animal group by large numbers of people, and the ease
with which the animal's perceived or imagined characteristics can be
anthropomorphized and rendered appealingly "special" in various ways
(Freeman and Kreuter, 1994; Kalland, 1994).
This paper will discuss the case of such a charismatic animal which appears
to have avoided animal protectionists' attention - attention that almost
invariably seeks to "save animals from extinction" by strenuously
opposing any commercial use of that animal. The charismatic species in question,
the polar bear is the largest of all the bear species, and being white in
colour, is immediately identified as an unusual and attractive creature. Bear
cubs in particular have immense popular appeal, as evidenced in the cute and
soft bear-likeness toys and characters featured in many children books and
stories.