|
European Brown Bear Compendium
William Alex Wall, Ph.D.
Senior Scientist of Wildlife Conservation
|

|
|
Conflicts and Threats
Wherever bears occur in Europe they come into conflict with human land uses
and activities, although the extent and nature of these conflicts vary widely
from country to country. Considering human population densities in Europe, the
existence of diverse conflicts is not surprising. The major conflict areas are
outlined below.
1) Livestock:
Bear predation on livestock is by far the most widespread
conflict. Although all species such as cattle, horses, goats and semi-domestic
reindeer can be killed by bears, depredation on domestic sheep is the most
serious and widespread conflict. Losses vary widely throughout Europe
(Kaczensky, 1996) depending on husbandry techniques. At the extreme end of the
spectrum is Norway, where sheep are grazed without supervision in forest
habitats during summer. A total of 15-30 bears kill 3000 - 4000 sheep each year
(around 100 sheep per bear per year). At the other end are countries in southern
and eastern Europe where sheep are constantly guarded by shepherds and guarding
dogs. Losses rarely exceed 5-10 sheep per bear per year. This illustrates that
while the potential for bear-livestock conflicts is enormous, there are
established methods to minimize it using traditional husbandry techniques
(Linnell et al., 1996). Modern solutions such as electric fencing are
also used successfully in countries like Sweden.
2) Beehives:
Bear damage to beehives is common throughout Europe and can
be of local economic importance. Traditional preventative methods have included
placing the hives on raised platforms or inside wooden structures. Modern
electric fences have also proved to be successful at preventing damage.
3) Crops:
Bear damage to orchards and crops is widespread, but not as
well documented as damage to beehives and livestock.
4) Game species:
Bear predation on wild ungulates is a potential source
of competition with human hunters. The problem is mainly confined to predation
on moose in the boreal forest habitats of the Scandinavian and the Northeastern
populations. The full impact of bear predation is still being discussed and
requires further research.
5) Bear – human interaction:
Bear attacks on people are generally very
rare in Europe but occasionally happen and can result in severe wounding or even
death of people. Romania is a possible exception, where attacks and deaths have
been far more common than in other parts of Europe. Reasons include the release
of non-European bears into the population, and the extreme high densities
created by the management system during the communist period (Swenson et al.,
1996). Bears that loose their shyness are a major conservation issue, especially
in small populations where every single bear is valuable for increasing the
population. Instead of shooting a nuisance bear aversive conditioning is often
tried first to discourage a bear from seeking food close to humans. These
measures include; shooting with rubber bullets, electric shocks, fire crackers
or chasing bears with dogs. Translocation of "problem bears" is very
rarely used in Europe (Linnell et al., 1997).
6) Other conflicts:
Many other minor conflicts exist such as damage to
containers of chain-saw oil, stores of grain and pellets used to feed wild
ungulates during winter, and even to fish ponds.
|