Most bears in farms were
captured from the wild during 1984 to 1989 before China Wildlife Protection Law
was issued. In that time less than 1,000 wild bears were sent to farms each year
on average, which was only 1.6% of wild bear population of China. Even if this
capture rate would be multiplied by 3 to compensate the mortality in capture, it
would still be less than the hunting pressure on American black bear (Ursus
americanus), which is 8% or 5.6% in North America. The capture
pressure on wild bears in China was very low and would not significantly
endanger the wild populations of bears of China.
5.2) Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCM) has a long history and will
develop further, and bear bile has been used as compatible with TCM for
thousands of years. China has a large market demand for bear bile. If it were
not satisfied with bile powder from bear farms, this demand would attract
poachers to kill wild bears, which would really endanger the survival of bears
in China, and even of bears in other countries.
5.3) The bile powder from bear farms provides the alternative resource to
bear gall bladders from the wild for traditional medicines. Enough supply of
bile powder from bear farms with low price and high quality reduces the poaching
pressure on wild bears. These have supported to protect wild bears in China and
will support wild bear conservation in the world when accepted by the
international community.
5.4) The improvement of pen facilities and the use of new operation by
opening fistula with self-tissue have avoided the mistreatment and torture of
farmed bears.
5.5) Annual yield and consumption of bile powder in China are stable.
There is a certain surplus of bile powder each year in China. The production of
the bile from farms has not stimulated market demand in China yet.
5.6) Almost half of farmed bears are bred in captivity now, including F1,
F2 and F3. The potential breeding bear stocks are great enough and the captive
breeding has to be controlled because of the surplus of the bile powder in China
and the international ban of the bile products of Asiatic black bear. Some large
bear farms in China have qualified the CITES criteria for registration of
operations breeding Appendix-I animal species for commercial purposes.