Santiago, 12 November 2002: Today’s decision by CITES to
authorize sales of stockpiled ivory provides a much needed boost to
elephant conservation programs in Africa, in line with principles strongly
advocated by IWMC World Conservation Trust for many years.
Eugene Lapointe, a former Secretary-General of CITES and now President
of IWMC, said: "African conservation is dependent on the money it can
obtain from ivory sales. Without this revenue, it is unrealistic to expect
these poor nations to finance the programs that are required to manage
elephant populations and ensure these wonderful creatures can flourish in
the long-term."
The decision came after an earlier agreement by African nations,
allowing South Africa, Zimbabwe, Namibia and Botswana to set small annual
quotas for ivory sales, was modified during the CITES COP12 meeting.
Conservation groups like IWMC argue that elephants can only be properly
protected if range states are permitted to undertake carefully controlled
sales of ivory to pay for their programs. Sales of small quantities of
ivory, collected from natural mortality and population management measures,
have provided the firm foundation for successful elephant conservation
programs in southern Africa in the past.
CITES has found no evidence to confirm a correlation, alleged by animal
rights protesters this week, that the ivory sales authorized by CITES in
1997 have led to increases in poaching. Even in Kenya, which supports a
ban, official records show no link between the two, with more deaths being
attributed to government protection of poor rural farmers, whose crops are
damaged by elephants, than illegal poaching. Moreover, the 1989 trade ban
failed to stop illegal trading in ivory.
Mr. Lapointe said: "Unfortunately ivory has become a political
battleground, with African countries wishing to utilize their resources in
a regulated manner and outsiders rushing to false judgments about
population sizes and false remedies on how to provide protection. Today’s
decision is a step in the right direction and will hopefully pave the way
for an agreed set of annual quotas at the next CITES meeting."
IWMC (International Wildlife Management Consortium) World Conservation
Trust is attending CITES COP12 as an official observer organization and is
actively participating in many of the discussions. It has several leading
academics and conservation experts from different continents among its
delegation.